Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What makes an ALPR cost more than $1000 per unit?


The starting value of felony


Probably the pole, footing, and wages for the installation crew.


A quick google reveals a Flock camera costs about $2500 and there's a few hundred dollars in install fees.


The markup I assume


All the reasons in the other repliues, and it's also not just an ALPR.


High quality cameras are expensive.


Equivalent quality cameras can be had for 100-200. Not that expensive.


In a weather-proof, UV-resistant housing, with battery and solar panel for charging, designed to meet municipal and traffic safety specs, and with turn-key service, all at the usual markup for dealing with all that and because there are almost no competitive alternatives, it sounds pretty typical.

Even a simple stop sign is hundreds of dollars when you consider all the costs associated with its installation.


Look up guardrail guy's video on their installs. They are not up to code. Even the newer installs that do include breakaways are failing.


https://store.ui.com/us/en/products/uvc-ai-lpr

$500 for one of the best [that I know of] consumer LPR cameras. Non-consumer versions go for thousands.


And the cameras Flock are using are no where near that good of quality. The claim was high quality cameras are expensive. Flock is using pretty cheap components. There's been multiple tear-downs showing just how budget built they are.


Framing Flock as just an ALPR always feels disingenuous to me. More charitably, it's at least naive.

And even if it WAS and will only ever be an ALPR, I'm incredulous that people would accept it.


Yes, stop calling them "ALPRs" because they're not. It's the surveillance industry's marketing wank to make them seem benign, limited, and a police tool when it's (and similar products) really a video/audio?/wifi?/bt?/sdr?* panopticon that generates fallible metadata about maybe you, maybe your car, and maybe your stuff that will be saved forever, to be offered for sale forever to almost any company, government, or individual in the world with money for any purpose.

They say they'll delete "data" in X days, but what they really mean is original source video only. There's no guarantee they'll delete anything else because their moneymaker is compiling sellable "histories" of and AI training data about people, vehicles, and other objects.

Streetlight light sensor ports are being used to retrofit lights with smart lights containing advanced neighborhood spy "cameras" with additional features. So there's more than just standalone or telephone pole-mounted "ALPRs".

* It's not a huge cost and there's obvious motivations to iterate to include additional sensors &| radios to gather additional raw data by using the fleet of "ALPRs" as a platform. Many "ALPRs" have microphones. Some smart streetlight ones do wifi/bt fingerprinting.


Go tear one down and see for yourself. We don't want to ruin the surprise for you.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: